Foto MARK ELLIDGE at timesonlineThis Halloween performance of Matilde di Shabran was the perfect date-night-out. If there was ever an operatic rom-com - this was it! It is definitely not the most accomplished Rossini creation, but in spite of being a good 3 hours 15 minutes long, it manages to be very entertaining. At least for me, once I got into it, it felt as if over in a flash!
Never mind the intrigue; it is all very obvious, in spite of the considerable number of characters on stage. It is all about the boy and girl :-)
It took some time for everyone to get going, but once they did, it was all smooth from there. The staging and direction (Mario Martone) is nothing special, but it also doesn’t disturb the music, which given the difficulty of some parts of the score is not such a bad thing. But it does put all the weight of the performance on the singers. It was entirely up to them to take the plot forward and give shape to their characters. And still in the ensemble scene with have some déjà vu moments, with the chorus in the back and the singers in the front, spread evenly across the stage, singing towards the audience.
foto Catherine AshmoreSo let’s then do as I did there and zoom in to the characters:
The biggest contribution to the recitative and the language came undoubtedly from the “poet” Isidoro (Alfonso Antoniozzi) .. I enjoyed his Neapolitan twang to the fullest and pity no translation could ever do it justice ( and as always some laughs were slightly timelagged due to this). He is an excellent actor and as his singing is reduced to a minimum (and this is rather weak compared to his acting) gives a delightful performance.
Marco Vinco as Aliprando (the good doc) has a warm and deep tone to his voice, perfectly suited for the role. And although in his first phrases he had a bit of trouble reaching into the audience, the volume then smoothly adjusted to fit perfectly with the orchestra. He is definitely a pleasure to listen to, making it all sound quite effortless. Belcanto indeed and not something encountered so often in a young bass-baritone and in a Rossini performance.
Mark Beesley as Raimondo didn’t particularly stand out for me, but I don’t think the score is very generous with him, not really giving him the opportunity to shine. His performance however was much more balanced than the other experienced and he didn’t seem to need the time to warm up. I’d like to hear him again in a more substantial role. Same is valid for the evil contessa sung correctly by Enkelejda Shkosa.
Vesselina Kasarova’s Edoardo sounded slightly strange to me, some brilliant upper parts and then suddenly a pit in the lower register, which comes totally unconnected to the rest. And I was a bit unpleasantly surprised to see the exact same mimic and gestures as earlier in the year in her Carmen. She is sometimes wonderful (and her 2nd aria got some well deserved applause), but makes you wish you heard her with your eyes closed.
Matilde/Aleksandra Kurzak - I did remember her from last November’s Adina, however I can’t say she made an impression on me then. Weeeelll, what a change!!! Fair to say I was blown away!!! The effortless singing, the cheeky character, the spunk of this Matilde! From the moment she appeared on stage you knew who would command this story. She more than once stole the show. And how’about Rossini??!!! In a 3 hour and a bit opera where do you put the most difficult coloratura for your soprano? At the very end of course, when she has already been singing for more than 2 hours!! Kudos to her, she looked at ease and totally in control all the way… I tell you, I would have been s*****g myself knowing what would come at the end! But she totally aced it! And the high notes were flowing playfully from those smiling lips and what you were left with was not the technical effort of the score but the personality and strength of this cute Matilde. Brava! Molto Brava! A Matilde to fall for and a singer to admire! And applaud they did, she got as many cheers, shouts and applause as JDF and that more than proves how well she’s earned the public’s admiration.
Ok, ok, I am getting there! I know what you all want to know, especially since I clearly said I had never heard HIM live before ;-))))
foto Catherine AshmoreOh, well what did you expect? I loved him, of course! :-)
Juan Diego Florez was an adorable Corradino and yes, he is very much lovable himself. He wasn’t applauded when he came on stage, but I think it was just because it was incredibly fast and the moment was gone; I believe it was also right. It would have been unfair from the public towards his colleagues as no performance really stands just because of one singer. And applause is there to reward somebody’s performance not just acknowledge their physical presence, however nice it may be ;-)))
Surprisingly, it wasn’t his voice that knocked me off my socks, it was his stage personality. Of course his voice is beautiful! But I had heard it in recordings before and he is every bit as good as those, which is a compliment, as few singers are as good live as their recordings. He too sounded a bit quiet for me for the first phrases, but he then found his zone and brought the house down on several occasions. I’m not saying anything new here when I mention that he doesn’t have a booming volume, but does anyone want to have their ears shattered in Belcanto?? I think not; I don’t give much credit for volume anyway, because that is mostly genetics and you don’t get many brownie points in the long run for the gifts of mother nature alone :-) What makes him special are not even those easy high notes that he throws with the ease others say good morning. It is his sweet and intense lyrical singing, with this silken mezza voce of his that really does you in. Your know Pour me rapproche a Marie? Well that is what I mean, that is where for me he is better than all the other belcanto tenors today. And for working hard to polish this part of his singing I admire him. He has them all at his feet with high Cs. Ds. Es and all the other letters of the alphabet he can do, but I appreciate that he doesn’t leave it at that and is intent at showing all the other things his voice has to offer. For this reason my favourite part voice-wise as Corradino was the bit in the last act when he thinks he has sent innocent Matilde to death himself. He was absolutely exquisite there and I long to hear him sing something like that again. By the way, he’s got amazing diction; considering the amount of words he had to pronounce during these coloraturas it is no small success that one could understand every word he uttered.
And did anyone every say he was bland and not the best actor? Well all the laughs you will hear in the radio broadcast are 90% his! He is unbelievably funny! His face never stops moving and his got 1000 of them; and he is not a bit afraid of making a fool of himself ( and mind you he is a very composed person outside stage ;-) ) I didn’t feel anything special for that winding staircase… that is until Juandi was jumping up and down on it and started crawling in and around the railing like a little koala! Unbelievably funny and it made you want to cuddle him then and there! And there were a gazillion moments like that, he was never out of character, singing or not. He is an incredible bundle of energy and character.
It looked as if he enjoyed himself immensely and it makes me wonder why would anyone want him to sing something as boring as the Duca, when there are a gazillion more interesting and fun roles out there that he can excel at, why be one of the pack when he can be the prince? Oh yes, of course he knows just how good he is and he graciously accepts the admiration. From what I saw this evening he’s found that good balance between being a star and knowing you are one and still being able to make fun of yourself, not taking yourself too seriously and being a good and generous colleague.
I have to give a very big Bravo to the orchestra and the maestro Carlo Rizzi! They made the very very very best of this score! They showed how classy they are and Rizzi is fun to watch, with his baguette elegantly changing hands or disappearing all together. He did an excellent job in my opinion and got me for the first time truly excited about his Trovatore in spring (even more so considering how they were dissing Il povero Trovatore during the insight ;-))))
I can only say how much I regret not being able to watch it one more time. Now that I know where the thrills are, musically speaking :-)
I’ll be counting down the day to my next Rossini, this time one on my top-3-know-it-by-heart list of all times! Il Barbiere with the adorable JDF and the amazing DiDonato (and for me the big unknown of the evening, Simon Keenlyside as Figaro).
This performance is broadcast on BBC Radio 3 on Saturday 22 November
