Friday, 15 January 2010

Werther (Jonas Kaufmann) : La plus belle voix au monde

Por cierto... Felicitats als meus amics de Barcelona, ells saben perqué ;-))) Me alegro tanto o mas que vosotros!!! :-)))


Photo Scholzshootpeople at JDD
Werther - (1892)MUSIC BY JULES MASSENET (1842-1912)
POEM BY EDOUARD BLAU, PAUL MILLIET AND GEORGES HARTMANN AFTER JOHANN WOLFG ANG VON GOETHE
Michel Plasson Conductor
Benoît Jacquot Stage Director
Charles Edwards Sets
Christian Gasc Costumes

Jonas Kaufmann Werther
Ludovic Tézier Albert
Alain Vernhes Le Bailli
Andreas Jäggi Schmidt
Christian Tréguier Johann
Sophie Koch Charlotte
Anne-Catherine Gillet Sophie

Paris Opera Orchestra and Chorus
Maîtrise des Hauts-de-Seine⁄ Paris Opera children's Chorus
Original Royal Opera House production, Covent Garden, London (2004), owned by the Opera national de Paris

A video from the lovely ESTI: Merci beaucoup!!!

And it wasn't me who said it :

First impressions from Paris:

Le JournalduDimanche - "Le héros de la soirée est le ténor allemand Jonas Kaufmann. Bien qu’il sorte épuisé de la fameuse mauvaise grippe au point d’avoir renoncé à chanter lors de la répétition générale, il a, hier soir, ébloui par une voix qui est sans doute la plus belle au monde, fulgurante, puissante avec un timbre rauque, une douceur ardente et poétique. Il a en outre tout pour lui : il est idéalement romantique avec un physique de jeune premier ombrageux, cheveux bouclés, regard langoureux. Sa diction en français, alors qu’il est de langue allemande, est impeccable. On comprend tout ce qu’il chante. Le fameux air "Pourquoi me réveiller, ô souffle du printemps" a été accueilli dans un silence intense."

AFP for LeMonde - "Voix idéalement sombre, fine musicalité, français soigné: le célèbre ténor allemand Jonas Kaufmann a fait jeudi soir à Paris des débuts captivants dans le rôle-titre du "Werther" de Massenet, campant avec justesse un jeune héros romantique sous l'oeil du cinéaste Benoît Jacquot... . Avec Jonas Kaufmann, le cinéaste est comblé: ce beau ténébreux au cheveux bouclés semble sorti de l'esprit de Goethe, dont "Les Souffrances du jeune Werther" inspireront à Jules Massenet son drame lyrique (1892). Son grain de voix concentré, la richesse de son timbre et sa maîtrise technique font merveille dans cette musique qui préfère le ton de la conversation à l'éclat. Le jeune quadragénaire offre notamment un "Pourquoi me réveiller" (acte III) de toute beauté. ... En peu de pas et de gestes, Jonas Kaufmann offre une forte présence. Son Werther esquisse un duo convaincant, où l'on se cherche, se frôle, s'évite ou s'étreint subtilement, avec la Charlotte de la mezzo française Sophie Koch, d'une sensibilité et d'un épanouissement remarquables. "

Le Monde review -"....Pour l'heure, Werther est incarné par "le" ténor du moment : l'Allemand Jonas Kaufmann. Timbre sublime (chaud, parfois "barytonant", "musqué"), musicalité exceptionnelle, très large palette de nuances, diction soignée (à quelques rares déviations phonétiques près). Ajoutez à cela des dons de comédien et une allure d'idole des matinées et vous obtenez un cocktail de qualités rarement réunies à l'opéra.....Peut-on oser tout de même l'expression d'une réserve ? S'il donne, grâce à un chuchotement extraordinaire, une crédibilité supplémentaire à la fin de l'ouvrage, le son "couvert" de sa voix, dans certaines nuances très douces, manque un peu de projection dans la grande salle de la Bastille, à laquelle on eût préféré le Palais Garnier. Mais Kaufmann attire les foules et la jauge de Bastille est plus importante que celle de l'opéra Garnier..."

Concertclassic - "Que Jonas Kaufmann paraisse avec ses lunettes de glacier et vous avez Werther devant vous. On aura beau gloser sur le timbre sombre – mais souvenons-nous que même George Thill mettait beaucoup d’ombre à son Werther – cette voix vous étreint, elle vous prend au plexus solaire, et dès deux paroles dites vous êtes vous aussi un peu Werther, transporté dans les secrets du personnage. "

L'Avant-Scène Opéra - "Gageons que si Massenet avait entendu son Werther chanté par Jonas Kaufmann, il n’aurait pas ressenti le besoin de recomposer sa partition dans une version pour baryton par dépit d’entendre une voix de ténor trop stentoriser son anti-héros. D’un raccourci familier, on pourrait dire que Kaufmann est le « deux-en-un » de la voix mâle : aigus projetés et couleur sombrée, exploit du forçage vocal propre à la tessiture de ténor – celui-là même qui dresse l’épiderme quand arrive le contre-Ut – et style suprêmement intérieur – ce qu’on aime chez nos grands barytons, cette noblesse élégante et pudique. A ceux qui préfèrent Philippe à Don Carlos, ou une forêt flamboyante d’été indien au soleil cru d’un port crétois, ou encore Maurice Ronet à Daniel Craig… on recommandera d’entendre une fois, un jour, Kaufmann chanter « Pourquoi me réveiller », enfin en point d’interrogation désolé et non en question vulgairement assenée – lui qui nous offre en outre une leçon de chant définitive. Palette de nuances et de registres en dégradés à faire frémir ses confrères ténors de la planète, diction de mélodiste français, subtilité et ductilité de la couleur et de l’intention : plus qu’un grand Werther ou qu’un grand ténor, un grand, très grand, musicien. Faut-il signaler quelques moments où l’on sentait le chanteur protéger une éventuelle fragilité du soir en n’osant pas tout donner… oui, pour ajouter encore à l’hommage au technicien, puisque même contenus, le style et l’idée étaient là."

Altamusica - "La présence même de Jonas Kaufmann, ténébreuse, presque chétive lors de son apparition durant le prélude, avant que Noël ait pollué l’air de juillet, dit tout cela immédiatement. Jamais son romantisme ne s’hystérise. Il est l’image d’une mélancolie intériorisée qui sitôt que la voix s’élève laisse absolument pantois devant la somptuosité d’un timbre puissamment mâle, dont le cuivre sait se lézarder en pianissimi rêvés. Dans un français toujours altier, le ténor allemand chante tout, absolument tout en poète. "

And here what do the opera goers say? read ODB

And there is a little video on arte.tv

Word of advice, if i may :-) Do read the entire reviews as the whole cast was excellent and Tezier, Koch and Gillet deserve the praise for their outstanding performance as well!

Oh and there was this article as well by Thierry Hilleriteau in Le Figaro in advance of the premiere, something about a .. "soleil noir" ;-)))) Definitely need to get myself a pair of proper sunglasses :-p

I'm thrilled!!! more to come :-)

14 comments:

  1. Can't wait for the next week...! I hope he will in better shape then... :-)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm sure he will Mei :-) But the flu comes with the cough so what can you do, it must make singing pure hell! How on earth do you control your breath when you get a cough fit?? I have no idea but apparently he found a way :-)

    But can you imagine how it an get even better than what people say was last night? :-))) great to look forward to that!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am going on Sunday. Hope there are no more cancellations on Eurostar.

    And Konigskindre in Zurich to look forward to.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Eurostar page says from tomorrow normal service, i checked myself frist think this morning, for obvious reasons ;-) And KK too, hope you'll enjoy it! I really like the music :-)

    Looking forward to both myself :-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm looking forward the TV broadcast...god bless Arte ;)

    ReplyDelete
  6. me too, me too as it will show allt hose details and the intimacy that you can't get in that .. um airport thingy they call Bastille ;-)))

    ReplyDelete
  7. I had the chance to be there - it was great! One could sense very high tension in the air as he was singing - everyone keeping their breath and admiring him. I will be there on Sunday - hope he will have overcome that cough, which he mastered so well that it was hardly noticeable. And then Zürich, Die Königskinder.
    By the way, thanks for the journal cuts.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh, lucky youu!!! i am slightly envious ;-) But only slightly, i'll join the crowds on Sunday as well and with a bit of luck i'll see a KK too, my first! :-) You are welcome about the papers, my pleasure. Since i was reading them anyway i thought why not share, surely other people want to know as well :-)

    And crossing fingers for Jonas to be cough free on Sunday! :-)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Airport?!?!!!!!??!! The Bastille?!!!!!!!??!? Mon chere, you must not have had the ... um ... pleasure of attendance at the Met.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Indeed i have not, not yet anyway :-) I hope that i will be able to be at the Met sometime soon (soon in my calendar meening 1, max 2 years from now), it needs very carefull planning, but hopefully will be possible :-) And the Bastille tomorrow will also be my first, maybe my opinion will be different from what people say, wouldn't be suprised. However, i like the ROH size - just right for singing and big enough to pack a crowd and an interesting production :-) By the way, sorry for not getting back to you about your interesting comments on Don Giovanni, Keenlyside and all those subjects, i might try and catch up on that in one of the next posts, as it it definitely worth coming back to :-) By the way, how do you like Werther, the opera? Looking forward to discussing this in a more extended posted once i have passed my first "live" exam :-))))

    ReplyDelete
  11. 1) Can't opine on Werther until I see a decent production decently played and sung. My two experiences at the Met found the principles (Hampson (baritone version) and Graham (generally one of my favorites but memorably out of tune on that occasion) and Alagna/Kasarava (yuk)) on crappy form. Production boring and poorly conducted. Sorry to be such a sourpuss but those were memorably problematic evenings. Really looking forward to your reviews on the proceeding at the Bastille, though.

    2) If you're planning a trip to the Met, next year's Walkure would seem a particularly appealing choice. New production, Terfel, Westbroek, Voigt debuting as Brunnhilde (well, you can't have everything) and some anonymous German chap as Sigmund.

    3) Covent Garden and Munich are my favorite places to hear and see Opera - just about ideal in terms of size and acoustics. Zurich is a close third. A little too small and a little dry but I must say that I enjoyed my very few experiences there immensely. If you were as far from the stage in Zurich as some seats are from the stage at the Met you'd probably be swimming in the Limmat (I'm not actually sure how much of an exaggeration that is). Very few visits to the Bastille but always good seats and great performances so only good impressions. Many more and more varied at the Met. Tomorrow should be exceptional.

    4) As I recall, my Don G, SK comments were, for some idiotic reason, attached to a Carmen post (but then again it always gets back to Da Ponte for me - did I mention that I saw SK as the Count in Munich - apprapos of the above item). (One of the things I saw at the Bastille was Figaro - see, I'm really bad that way - but the Figaro was stupendous)


    5) I'v been told and have had the impression that I should find Koch more attractive than I do. Hmm.


    Have a great time tomorrow. Review eagerly anticipated.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 1) i like Graham sining when Charlotte i dunno :-S .. i know what you mean by yuk ;-))) My fav Werther so far, considering i've never seen it live before is Thill, definitely!
    2) really?? that idea never crossed my mind! ;-)))) i love Terfel and i really liked his Hollander, a bit unsure about this German chap.. (seeing as that particular aria on his last CD is my favourite of all...)
    3)totally with you! Munich has wonderful acoustics too, well except for the balconies when you are deep under the roof of another balcony, not so great and too much sauna, i'll try to avoid those in the future. You are spot on about Zurich and the Limmat, i sat right at the back and will sit there again ( not liking the prices there that much :-)) I find the acoustics there depend on the seat and hight of orchestra in the pit, sometimes they are too high up and the trumpets and horns bounce off the wooden back of the pit horribly, walling off the singers, but considering other house are worse, yes, probably these 3 are the best :-)
    4) yes something like that, i'm sure we will invariably come back to the same as i like Mozart and will be seeing loads of it soon, including Nozze:-) And in a year or two there will be the Da Ponte trilogy at the ROH, great! Mozart at the Bastille, oh my:-)
    5) hmm ideed, i liked her Brangane, but i find her more elegant and refined that attractive per se, she is an interesting artists and women from what i can tell from her interviews. Beautiful in her own special way i find. I wasn't sure about her voice in Brangane, but can't say as it was the first time hearing her live. I'll know after Charlotte for sure i guess :-)
    thanks!!! i am gittery ;-)) as anyone can tell because i write/speak too much ;-)))

    ReplyDelete
  13. Reve!Exstase!Bonheur!

    Definitive Werther yesterday at the Bastille. Both JK and Koch superb both in heart breaking intimacy and the terrrible outbursts of regret and lost apportunities. No wonder Massenet was known as Mme Wagner after this piece as you need Jugendlich dramatisch voices to do justice to these roles.

    I was wary in advance of the production having seen its previously at the ROH with Alvarez, well sung but no way near the romantic solipsism needed and the Charlotte was bland. Even in the huge spaces of the Bastille the tension of the unbearable 3 Act wait for Werther to actually touch Charlotte.

    The Third Act was the greatest with Koch passionate and intimate in the Airs des Lettres and then Larmes and then JK in the Lied d'Ossian. All greeted in rapt silence.

    At his first entrance with dark glasses Jonas looked like a refugee from 60's Carnaby Street (showing my age here) and embodied the destructive narcissm of the character- always "moi, moi". No sign thankfully of the "grippe" he was suffering at the first night and his dark timbre ' sustained soft singing and forceful attack were equal to the suicidal outburst of Act 2 and the final, almost benediction as the children's voices carol off stage in the last scene.

    Almost flawless playing from the orchestra and with charactersically lachrymose French style horn playing.

    It needed Koch and JK to be able to sustain some very slow tempi from Plasson and I was beginning to worry if I would catch my Eurostar back.

    Finally an ideal role for Le Texier - dull and grey.

    Re: the comments above regarding SK. As you probably know Massenet wrote a baritone version of the role of Werther. After the similarity of timbre of JK and JK in the ROH Don Carlo that would be intersting casting.

    And who was that demented creature in the Foyer at the end screeching " j'ai perdu mon chariot!"

    ReplyDelete
  14. :-) yep, an almost lifechanging experience indeed, musical lifeexperience anyway :-)
    I actually like Tezier and don't find him grey, maybe too restrained sometimes...

    But more on everything later when i survive work..

    By the way around me there were a lot of people speaking English, seems like a significant bunch of went too seek out the bonheur on a Sunday at La Bastille :-)
    I definitely feel like i have found it there...

    ReplyDelete

This blog is moderated, comments need to be approved by author